New Products    Books & Maps    Archival Products   Printing & Binding   Software   News & How-To   Upcoming Events   Contact Us  

Find Products


Popular Categories

   Canada
   England & Wales
   Ireland & Northern Ireland
   Scotland
   United Empire Loyalists
   USA
   more countries...

   Genealogy How-To
   Conservation How-To

   Genealogy Charts, Forms
   Magnifiers


























Forgotton Hero, Alexander Fraser
[War 1812 & Perth, Ontario]






The Famine in Ulster
[Northern Ireland]











News & How-To
Formerly branded as GlobalGazette.ca

Articles, press releases,and how-to information for everyone interested in genealogy and history

Subscribe to our free newsletter

Advertisement - Canadian resources

Discover your family's story.

Enter a grandparent's name to get started.

Start Now

Gordon Watts Reports
Column published: 30 August 2007
By: Gordon A. Watts   Biography & Archived Articles


Gordon A. Watts
Topics in this month's column include:
  • Meetings in Ottawa - Canadian Census


  • Library and Archives Canada cut hours


Scroll down this page to read the complete articles...



It has been a longer than normal period since my last column was published. For that I apologize. My main excuse (among many) for this might be put down to temporary insanity as I have done some travelling in the meantime - including a quick trip to Ottawa to talk with bureaucrats, and pulling my fifth wheel trailer through Saskatchewan in 40 plus degrees (C) weather. Twice during my trip through the Prairie Provinces we had to sit for several hours because my brother's Class A motor home decided to vapour-lock the fuel line and we had to wait for it to cool down before being able to continue down the road.

As it happens, I am still on the road, so to speak, sitting this morning at 6:00 am trying to finish this column, at an RV park 100 km from home. I am waiting for the arrival of my daughter and two of my grandchildren who will be staying with me for the Labour Day weekend. Travelling and visiting with friends and family has been enjoyable, but it is not conducive to sitting down and writing a column. As such, this column has been limited to only two articles - they are however, both very important articles that will require the eventual participation of many of my faithful readers. So, without further ado, here we go.



Meetings in Ottawa

As reported in my last column, in July I travelled to Ottawa to participate in meetings with representatives from Statistics Canada, and from the Offices of the Privacy and Information Commissioners of Canada. In addition to myself, there were three members of the Canadian Historical Association attending these meetings - Craig Heron, Professor of History at York University, and current President of the Canadian Historical Association; Eric Sager - Professor of History at University of Victoria, and researcher on the Canadian Families Project and the Canadian Century Research Infrastructure Project; and Kris Inwood - Professor of Economics at University of Guelph, and researcher on the 1891 Census of Canada Project.

The purpose of these meetings was to express our concerns regarding the poor positive response to the 'informed consent' question now imposed on the 2006 and subsequent Censuses, and to seek support for an early review of the administration and operation of the 'question' as mandated in the Statistics Act. The meetings were held on Monday 16 July and Tuesday 17 July 2007. (See my column posted 24 April 2007 for details of the poor positive response on the 2006 Census)

The first meeting we attended (10:00 AM Monday 16 July 2007) was with representatives of the Office of the Information Commissioner. Present were Andrea Neill - Assistant Commissioner, Complaints Resolution and Compliance; Sharon Nadeau - Assistant Director, General Investigations and Reviews; Dan O'Donnell - Chief, Operations Directorate; Larry Kearley - Senior Legal Advisor; and Marc-Aurèle Racicot - Research and External Relations.

Craig Heron began by introducing the members of our panel, and briefly explained the purpose of requesting a meeting. Eric Sager, followed by Kris Inwood, expressed concerns regarding the 'informed consent' question from the point of view of historians, and then I did the same from the point of view of genealogists. Each of us expressed the importance of seeking an early implementation of the review mandated in Bill S-18 (and now in the Statistics Act) and sought the support of the Office of the Information Commissioner in that endeavour.

Our presentations were received cautiously and politely, and perhaps with some sympathy, but without commitment to anything. As a government agency they perhaps did not wish to be seen as attacking legislation passed by Parliament only two years earlier. They expressed some concern about just what we were seeking from them, and may have been relieved to hear that we simply wished them to be supportive when the matter of an early review was brought up for consideration.

Anil Arora, director general of Statistics Canada's census branch
Anil Arora, Director General of
Statistics Canada's Census Programs
Branch, and Census Manager
The second meeting (2:00 PM Monday 16 July 2007) was with representatives of Statistics Canada. Present were Anil Arora - Director General, Census Programs Branch, and Census Manager; Dale Johnston - Assistant Director, Census Communications; and Dr. Rosemary Bender - Director General, Social and Demographic Statistics.

As was the case in our earlier meeting, Craig Heron introduced the members of our panel. We then presented our concerns as we had to the representatives of the Office of the Information Commissioner. The response from the StatCan representatives was perhaps a little more cautious than that from the previous meeting. This may have been because the concerns we expressed had a more direct effect on them than they did on the Offices of either the Information or Privacy Commissioners.

During our discussions here, because of the times involved in preparing for each Census, we were made even more conscious of the need to press for an immediate review. Even should we be successful in gaining an immediate review, and such a review could expeditiously make recommendations for change, it is a certainty that such changes could not be implemented in time for the 2011 Census, or possibly even for the 2016 Census. Even should any significant change, i.e. removal of the question or changing the 'opt-in' aspect of it to 'opt-out', be immediately recommended, we could be looking at the 2021 Census before it is implemented.

One area in which some hope of improvement exists is in the wording of the question, and arrangements were made for some future dialogue between us. There was discussion regarding improvements needed in advertising to promote a positive response. There was discussion also regarding the reasons respondents answered 'NO' or did not answer. Subsequent to our meeting, Statistics Canada has undertaken to study the 'NO' and 'no answer' responses and to conduct some research, i.e. focus groups and one-on-one interviews, into the reasons for them. Members of our panel have been invited to sit in on some of the focus groups.

Anil Arora, director general of Statistics Canada's census branch
Jennifer Stoddart
Privacy Commissioner of Canada
Our meeting with Privacy Commissioner Jennifer Stoddart took place at 4:00 PM, Tuesday 16 July 2007. Attending with her were Carman Baggaley, Strategic Policy Advisor, and Elizabeth (my apologies for not remembering her surname and position). Because Craig Heron had been unable to stay for this meeting, Eric Sager did the introductions of our panel and took the lead in expressing our concerns. As was the case in the other meetings, Kris Inwood spoke next, and I followed. Our discussions followed a similar path to those that took place in our previous meetings. There was one difference however, in that Information Commissioner Jennifer Stoddart specifically stated her support for an early review of the 'question'.

At first glance it might seem that these meetings have accomplished nothing concrete. However, those who believe that would be mistaken. By meeting with representatives of Statistics Canada and the Offices of the Information and Privacy Commissioners we have served notice that the historians and genealogists of Canada do not take the devaluation of historic Census records lightly, and that we will continue to lobby government to seek the removal of the 'informed consent' provision from future Censuses. The Census is perhaps the most important record of Canada's history. We do not believe that anyone should be able to opt out of history by not giving permission for his or her Census information to be made publicly available in 92 years.

My report here would not be complete without thanking Craig Heron and Eric Sager for initiating these meetings. Thanks go also to the Canadian Historical Association for providing the funding to allow me to travel to Ottawa in order to participate in them.



Library and Archives Canada cut hours

Anil Arora, director general of Statistics Canada's census branch
Library and Archives Canada
Wellington Street, Ottawa
I have recently received a number of emails from individuals concerned with an announcement on the Library and Archives website home page. Those who have bookmarked the URL for direct access to LAC's Canadian Genealogy Centre rather than going though the home page may have missed this important announcement that will affect anyone who accesses, or plans to access, the record rooms of the National Library and Archives in Ottawa. LAC is cutting the hours of operation for those wishing to visit the building at 395 Wellington Street.

Effective 1 September 2007 the reduced hours of operation, as taken from the LAC website will be as follows:
    The following services will be staffed and open to the public Monday to Friday, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m.

    • Telephone service
    • Registration desk
    • Reference rooms
    • Canadian Genealogy Centre
    • Consultation rooms: textual records, restricted documents, audiovisual records and microfilm
    • Consultation room for special collections (consultation of unpublished material will be by appointment only)

    In addition to the regular hours of service, certain rooms will be accessible but unstaffed during the following hours.

    • Monday to Friday, 8:30 to 10 a.m. and 4 to 8 p.m.
      • Consultation rooms: textual records, restricted documents, audiovisual records and microfilm

    • Saturdays and Sundays, 12 to 6 p.m.
      • Consultation rooms: textual records, restricted documents, audiovisual records and microfilm
      • Canadian Genealogy Centre

    All research facilities will be closed on statutory holidays, including Labour Day, September 3, 2007.
I am advised that the manned hours for telephone inquiries, the registration desk and reference rooms are each reduced from 42.5 hours, to 30 hours. Manned hours for consultation rooms is reduced from 105 hours to 54.5 hours, and for the Canadian Genealogy Centre they are reduced from 75 hours to 30 hours.

Library and Archives explains the change in hours of operation as follows:
    "Library and Archives Canada is committed to providing quality services to all Canadians, wherever they live. To honour this commitment, we are adjusting our hours of operation, in keeping with the anticipated needs of clients and evolving information technologies. We are steadily adding documentary heritage material to our website, thereby increasing access to the collection for Canadians both in the National Capital Region and across the country."
The documentary heritage material, in particular the scanned digital images of Census records and other information, that LAC has added to their website in recent years is welcome, and very much appreciated. The addition of this information to the website has made it available to many people that might otherwise be unable to access it. I am certain that the availability of this added information will have increased the interest of many researchers in attending the archives in Ottawa in person. There is nothing like the feeling of finding the information you seek through the 'hands on' experience gained while researching in our Nation's central repository of historical documents. All of this is reason to increase the hours of manned operation, or at least maintain the 'status quo', rather than reducing those hours.

The reduced hours will have a drastic effect on local patrons who work during the day and are unable to attend LAC during the reduced hours of operation. Those who travel to Ottawa with the express purpose of visiting and researching at the archives will be adversely affected as well. The stated reason for the change in hours is to provide "quality services to all Canadians, wherever they live". One must wonder however, how reducing the hours during which there will be staff available for patron assistance is an improvement. I suspect that rather than an attempt to 'improve service', the reasons for the reduced hours are more monetary than otherwise. I can see the parent Ministry of Library and Archives Canada (Heritage Canada) applying pressure to reduce operating expenses by reducing the manned hours of operation and the number of employees required to provide that service.

It is my understanding that, unlike past changes that have affected public access to the library and archives, there has been no prior public consultation leading up to these changes in hours of operation. Patrons have had no opportunity to provide input as to how such changes would affect their access. It is my feeling that public consultations should have taken place before such changes were made. All is not lost however, and those adversely affected by these changes can still make their views known. LAC's announcement included a method to do this by including the following note:
    "Should you have comments or questions, you may wish to contact Antonio Lechasseur, Director, Client Services Division at web@lac-bac.gc.ca or 613-996-5115 or 1-866-578-7777 (toll-free in Canada and the United States); TTY: 613-992-6969 or 1-866-299-1699 (toll-free in Canada)."
I strongly suggest that anyone affected by the announced changes - whether a local researcher or someone planning a trip to visit the archives, should take advantage of this opportunity to make known your views on the changed hours of operation. In so doing I would suggest your message be copied to Ian Wilson, Librarian and Archivist of Canada, to The Hon. Josée Verner, Minister for Canadian Heritage" and to your Member of Parliament.



Until next time.

Gordon A. Watts gordon_watts@telus.net

Your comments regarding this newsletter, and suggestions for future articles are welcome. Click here to send me a message with a subject line of "Gordon Watts Reports".

To view back issues of Gordon Watt's columns, visit Gordon's biography page where all of his archives articles are available.


Canadian Genealogy & History Resources from Global Genealogy:



© GlobalGenealogy.com Inc. 1992-2014
Shop: GlobalGenealogy.com | News: News & How-To | Publishing: Our titles | MyBook: Printing & Binding
Sign up for our free newsletter! | Unsubscribe from our newsletter