News & How-To
Formerly branded as GlobalGazette.ca
Articles, press releases,and how-to information for everyone interested in genealogy and history
Subscribe to our free newsletter
Article Published April 29, 2005
POST-1901 CENSUS NEWS (Canada)
By: Gordon A. Watts, firstname.lastname@example.org
Greetings Readers, and Members of Parliament
Progress of Bill S-18
Following a two-week break, the Senate of Canada resumed sitting on Tuesday 12 April 2005. Contrary to our hopes and expectations they did not resume Third Reading debate of Bill S-18 at this time. According to the daily Journal, Bill S-18 was called and postponed 'until the next sitting'.
Debate resumed on Wednesday 13 April 2005 with Senator Wilfred P. Moore (Liberal - Nova Scotia) speaking against the access to Historic Census records sought by genealogists and historians. Since March of 2002, when he expressed support for Senator Milne's Private Senator Bill S-12, Senator Moore had been shown on our Scoreboard having a Gold Tick of Support. No more! It seems that the good Senator did a complete about-face regarding public access to Historic Census records. His comments during his speech left little doubt as to his opposition and as such his Gold Tick of Support has been removed. The Scoreboard now shows him having a Red X of Opposition.
As have other Senators (and some MPs) who have spoken against the access we seek to regain, he made frequent references to 'promises' that have been proven never to have existed. Like others have done, he quoted two narrow clauses of the 1918 Statistics Act while ignoring all pertinent clauses of Instructions to Officers and Enumerators of Census from 1901 to at least 1946 (all having the Force of Law) referring to records of Census having value as historical documents, and being stored in the 'Archives of the Dominion' for research in the future. He ignored the fact that clauses in the Access to Information and Privacy Acts, and Privacy Regulations make provision, clearly and unambiguously, for access by any person or body for purposes of research 92 years after the Census is collected.
As we have come to expect, the Honourable Senator Comeau got his two-bits worth in once more. He made reference to individuals using Census to obtain clues relating to health concerns and then expressed concern that insurance companies could use such information to limit what kind of insurance coverage could be obtained. The fact is that Census does not give specific information relating to health concerns, but only gives vague clues on where such information might be found. For such information to be of use to insurance, or any other companies, they would be compelled to compile a multi-generation genealogy for each person seeking to purchase a policy. The likelihood of any company doing this costly and time-consuming exercise is extremely remote. We view the expressed concern of Senator Comeau in this regard simply as scare-mongering.
The debate was adjourned in the name of Senator Lynch-Staunton. No further debate on Bill S-18 took place in the Senate until Tuesday 19 April 2005, when it received its final debate with Senator Lynch-Staunton (as usual) speaking against the Bill. As seems to be the case regardless of who is speaking to the Bill, the Honourable Senator Comeau got his comments in once again.
Senator Lowell Murray, with whom I have been at odds almost from the beginning of our campaign to regain access to Historic Census records, spoke in support of Bill S-18, indicating his intention to vote in favour of it. I was convinced of the sincerity of his support at this time, and for that I finally awarded him a Gold Tick on the Senators Scoreboard. I will be writing to him to express my personal thanks for his support at this time.
Unlike previous reports where I have elaborated on the debate, I simply suggest you read this session for yourselves. The Hansard extract of all debates have been posted to the Post 1901 Census Project website at the URL following my signature. Follow the link for 'Progress of Bill S-18'.
Bill S-18 passed in the Senate with a verbal vote of Yeas/Nays, however a recorded vote was called for. On Wednesday 20 April 2005 the Senate of Canada voted 51 to 16 to pass Third Reading of Bill S-18 - An Act to amend the Statistics Act. The following charts show the way the Honourable Senators voted:
THE HONOURABLE SENATORS
THE HONOURABLE SENATORS
Bill S-18 received First Reading in the House of Commons on Thursday 21 April 2005.
Your assistance requested - again
While Bill S-18 has received First Reading in the House of Commons, at this time there is no indication regarding when debate in Second Reading will take place. Unlike Senate procedures, where an item remains on the Orders of the Day continuously and may be dealt with at any time, the Order Paper in the House of Commons works very differently. In the House of Commons only those items on the Projected Order of Business can be debated on any given day in the House. As I write this the House of Commons is in recess for the week of 25 April. For the week of 2 May, Bill S-18 does not as yet appear on the Projected Order of Business.
With your help we hope that this can be changed. We would like everyone reading this to send an email message to the leaders of all political Parties in Ottawa to encourage further debate of Bill S-18 to be completed and passed in a single sitting of the House of commons. Send that message to the following people, with a copy to your own Member of Parliament.
This may be the most important request we have made in the course of our campaign. We need everyone reading this to climb aboard. If you have ever, or never, written a letter or email supporting our campaign, now is the time to do so.
Please write immediately you read this column. If you do not, it may be too late. Time is rapidly running out for Bill S-18 to be passed before Parliament is recessed for the summer. Should an election be forced upon us before Bill S-18 is passed it will mean we have to start over one more time.
Letter from Ontario Genealogical Society
The following letter was sent on behalf of the Ontario Genealogy Society by Past-President David MacKenzie.
40 Orchard View Blvd., Suite 102,
Toronto, Ontario, M4R 1B9
April 21, 2005
To Party Leaders and House Leaders,
The Parliament of Canada.
Ms. Davies and Gentlemen:
I am officially writing to you on behalf of the more than six thousand members of the Ontario Genealogical Society, but I am sure that I also speak for the tens of thousands of family historians in this country who are not members of our Society.
The Senate has now adopted Bill S-18. This bill clarifies and eliminates any ambiguity that may have existed concerning the release of census information to the National Archives 92 years after to census has been taken.
Access to this information is often the only tool available to a family historian to research and find the members of a given family or this information may lead the researcher to other important avenues of information. Allow me to give you an example:
I live in Brockville, Ontario. By means of mail and e-mail I answer questions that come to me from individuals who are all over this continent and even overseas. These people are searching their family history in our region where the Loyalists settled in the 1780's. Not too long ago I received a request from a lady in Oklahoma who was able to furnish me only with the name of her great grandmother and the fact that this lady was supposed to have died in our region around 1912. Searching in the registers of the local cemeteries I was able to find her tombstone that indicated not only the date of death of the woman, but also the name of her husband and the date of this death as well (1904). I therefore concluded that they had probably lived in the region at the time of the 1901 census. I therefore searched the registers of this census and found them. I was able to find their dates of birth, the fact that they were both born in Scotland and were members of the Presbyterian Church. This led me to search the registers of the Presbyterian Church where I found the documents recording the births and marriages of their children. Using this information the lady from Oklahoma traveled to Scotland where with the dates from the census, she was able to find several other generations of her family.
In this and several other cases, access to the census was essential to enable the searcher to trace his or her roots. The 92-year delay provides adequate protection of the privacy of personal information
This Bill has wide support. The Privacy Commissioner, the National Archivist, the Chief Statistician, The Information Commissioner and the Canadian Historical Association all support this Bill, as does our Society. 209 members of the current parliament have indicated their support All of you have indicated your support. This is not a partisan issue. In this precarious parliament speed might be of the essence. Please get all parties together and pass the Bill in a single day.
Your help will be most appreciated.
David A. Mackenzie,
Past President, OGS
The following letter from Wayne Metcalf, Vice President of the Genealogical Society of Utah was sent to MPs Tony Valeri, David Emerson, Jay Hill, Stephen Harper, Libby Davies and Jack Layton. A French language version of this letter was sent to the leaders of the Bloc Quebecois. The letter is copied here with permission.
To: Valeri.T@parl.gc.ca; Emerson.D@parl.gc.ca; Hill.J@parl.gc.ca; Harper.S@parl.gc.ca; Davies.L@parl.gc.ca; Layton.J@parl.gc.ca
Sent: Tuesday, April 26, 2005 2:01 PM
Subject: Senate Bill 18 in the House of Commons
April 26, 2005
Dear Parliamentary Leaders:
I am writing to respectfully request passage of Senate Bill 18 in the House of Commons.
My name is Wayne Metcalfe, and I am Vice President of the Genealogical Society of Utah ("GSU"), which is affiliated with The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. The Church operates the largest family history library in the world in Salt Lake City, Utah, U.S.A., with 4,500 branches worldwide, including 154 branches in Canada. These branches serve approximately 172,000 Canadian citizens annually.
As you are aware, Senate Bill 18 authorizes the release of census information 92 years after its collection. Census information is of vital interest to family historians and genealogists. The bill represents a compromise and is supported by 209 current members of Parliament. It passed the Senate by a vote of 51-16. The Information Commissioner, Privacy Commissioner, Chief Statistician, National Archivist, Canada Census Campaign, and Canadian Historical Association all support the bill.
Statistics Canada needs a decision on the bill in the near term so that final preparations may be made for the 2006 Census.
We acknowledge that this may be a difficult time for the House, but Senate Bill 18 is not controversial; it is a non-partisan bill.
GSU takes no position on whether or not there should be an election, only that it is vital to pass Senate Bill 18 in the House of Commons prior to any election. Therefore, GSU joins many other interested groups and citizens in respectfully urging the House to pass Senate Bill 18 in one day.
Thank you very much for your consideration of this important matter.
Genealogical Society of Utah
Join the Canada Census Campaign mail list
To join in List Mode, send an email to
For those who may not yet have noticed, it is possible to send this column to a friend (or your MP). A window below allows you to input an email address to send it to, and allows you to insert a few comments regarding it. Feel free to forward any of my columns to anywhere you feel there may be an interest in it.
Until next time. Happy Hunting.
Gordon A. Watts email@example.com
Post 1901 Census Project Web Site: http://globalgenealogy.com/Census
en français http://globalgenealogy.com/Census/Index_f.htm